Maui prosecutor disputes police chief's claim that mayor was under investigation

Oct 14, 2026

A public fight between Maui's top law enforcement officials is escalating, which is bad news for public trust in the county government.

  • Maui's prosecuting attorney, Andrew Martin, says Police Chief John Pelletier told the public something untrue when he claimed Mayor Richard Bissen was the target of a criminal investigation.
  • Martin's point: agencies do not name people under investigation unless there is enough evidence for an arrest or charge, and naming the mayor broke that basic rule.
  • Pelletier was put on paid leave last week after a vote by the police commission.
  • Pelletier says the leave is payback for two investigations involving the mayor.
  • His attorney stayed silent on the prosecutor's rebuttal.

Outlook: Expect more public sparring and pressure on the police commission to explain the leave decision as both sides dig in.

← Latest · Archive