How Prediction Markets Are Taking Over America
Prediction markets like Kalshi and Polymarket are growing fast with almost no federal oversight, and that is bad news for ordinary users, who mostly lose money.
- Because these apps are treated as financial exchanges rather than gambling, they operate in all 50 states while sports betting apps are limited state by state.
- Most accounts lose money, and a tiny sliver of traders takes home the bulk of the profits — users have lost roughly half a billion dollars on Kalshi alone.
- Sports bets make up most of the trading, so in practice these apps work like sportsbooks with looser rules and an 18-and-up age limit instead of 21.
- Insider trading is a real problem: a Columbia law professor puts it in the hundreds of millions on Polymarket, and George Santos profited betting on his own attendance at a Trump speech.
- Trump's administration shows no interest in regulating, and Don Jr. sits on boards tied to the two biggest platforms.
Outlook: States like Ohio, Tennessee, and Minnesota are pushing back in court after a federal appeals court said they can enforce their gambling laws, setting up a fight likely headed to the Supreme Court.