Maui Police Chief Stays on Leave Amid Unit Investigation

Nov 20, 2026

Maui's police commission voted to keep Chief John Pelletier on paid leave, a setback for him but a win for critics demanding accountability over a troubled unit in his department.

  • The commission voted 6-1 to keep Pelletier off the job while it investigates his oversight of the department's criminal intelligence unit.
  • That unit's former commander faces federal bribery and corruption charges, and a former assistant police chief testified the department needs new leadership.
  • Pelletier's attorney says there's no evidence of wrongdoing by the chief and plans to sue the commission and the commissioners who voted against him.
  • The police officers union is urging both sides to resolve the dispute quickly, warning that a prolonged fight will hurt the department and public safety.

Outlook: Pelletier's legal team plans to file a lawsuit against the commission next week, setting up a legal fight over his leave status.

← Latest · Archive