Maui Police Commission Expands Probe Into Chief Pelletier
Maui's police oversight board is widening its investigation into suspended Chief John Pelletier, a sign the controversy around him is growing rather than fading — bad news for Pelletier and potentially costly for county taxpayers.
The commission has split its inquiry into three separate investigations while Pelletier stays on paid leave. One looks at whether he failed to properly oversee a lieutenant now facing federal bribery and drug conspiracy charges. A second examines his department's handling of a fireworks-related property damage case tied to that same lieutenant's associates, after a family affected by the incident said police backed off once a connection to the lieutenant became clear. A third, not yet formally launched, would look at whether Pelletier broke policy with public statements he made about the department, the mayor, and ongoing investigations after being placed on leave.
The expanded investigation is being run by an outside law firm under a new contract expected to cost over fifty thousand dollars over six months, paid out of the police department's own budget.
The case has become entangled with a separate lawsuit from the mayor's former chief of staff, who accused the mayor of covering up misconduct — a claim the commission's attorney says is fueling scrutiny of whether any funds were misused. No criminal charges have been filed over that civil suit, and a lawsuit from Pelletier himself over how the commission handled his leave is considered likely.
Outlook: Expect depositions and formal findings in the coming months, with legal fights from multiple directions — the lieutenant's criminal case, the mayor's civil suit, and a likely suit from Pelletier — all converging around the same underlying dispute.