Former Maui mayor says police chief dispute shouldn't drag in the mayor's office

Nov 20, 2026

A political fight over Maui's sidelined police chief is heating up, with the chief's backers accusing the mayor of pulling strings behind the scenes.

  • The Maui Police Commission voted 6 to 1 to keep Chief John Pelletier on paid leave while a private investigation continues, a process expected to take months and cost tens of thousands of dollars.
  • Supporters packed a hearing demanding Pelletier's reinstatement, claiming Mayor Richard Bissen pushed the commission to sideline him; commissioners and the mayor's office both deny any influence.
  • Critics of Pelletier say he's defied the commission and acted without authority, especially after a close colleague was arrested by federal agents for allegedly protecting drug traffickers.
  • Pelletier's attorney plans to file a lawsuit and calls the mayor a bully; a former county mayor pushed back, saying county rules bar the mayor from having any say in hiring or firing the police chief.

Outlook: A lawsuit from Pelletier's camp is expected next week, keeping the leadership standoff — and the police department's instability — unresolved for months.

← Latest · Archive