Public Testimony Splits Sharply Over Maui Police Chief's Future

Nov 18, 2026

Dozens of residents and officers testified at a Maui police commission meeting over whether to reinstate Chief John Pelletier, who was put on leave after a top intelligence officer under him was arrested, and the crowd was deeply split.

  • Many retired officials, a department chaplain, a helicopter contractor, and current officers praised Pelletier for modernizing the department, adding a K9 unit, a helicopter program, and boosting recruitment and morale, and urged his reinstatement.
  • Supporters pointed to his handling of the Lahaina wildfire aftermath, including identifying nearly all fire victims, and said he should not be blamed for a subordinate's alleged misconduct since he was not implicated and acted once he learned of it.
  • Native Hawaiian testifiers pushed back hard, describing unlawful arrests, land-dispute harassment, and a department budget that nearly doubled under Pelletier while, they argued, doing little for Native Hawaiian or unsheltered communities.
  • Critics also questioned why a lieutenant's misconduct went unaddressed for months, raised conflict-of-interest concerns about contractors testifying in support of the chief, and noted that no current officer willing to criticize him showed up to speak.
  • A county attorney requirement means executive session deliberations on the chief's fate may need to happen in open session under state sunshine law, something several testifiers specifically demanded.

Outlook: The commission is expected to move into (contested) executive or open session to decide whether Pelletier returns to duty, with the decision likely to hinge on the federal investigation into the arrested lieutenant and how much responsibility is attributed to the chief's oversight.

← Latest · Archive