Maui Police Commission Votes to Keep Chief Peltier on Paid Leave

Nov 18, 2026

Maui's police commission voted to keep embattled chief John Peltier on paid administrative leave while an investigation continues, a move his attorney says violates the county charter and could trigger a lawsuit.

  • The commission voted 6-1 to keep Chief Peltier on leave pending an independent investigation into oversight of the department's criminal investigative unit.
  • The chief's attorney argued the commission skipped required steps — no public hearing, no specific charges stated, no due process — and threatened to sue if the commission doesn't start over.
  • He also raised a conflict-of-interest claim, saying the mayor opposed Peltier from before his hiring and has pushed privately and publicly for his firing.
  • Commissioners defended the leave as a temporary, protective step meant to preserve records and investigative integrity, not as discipline.
  • A commissioner asked Peltier to submit a written plan for restoring trust and accountability in the department if reinstated, due by Monday.

Outlook: Legal conflict looks likely to escalate, with the chief's attorney signaling he'll file suit and seek depositions from commissioners unless the process restarts with a formal hearing.

← Latest · Archive