Maui Police Commission Votes to Keep Chief Peltier on Paid Leave
Maui's police commission voted to keep embattled chief John Peltier on paid administrative leave while an investigation continues, a move his attorney says violates the county charter and could trigger a lawsuit.
- The commission voted 6-1 to keep Chief Peltier on leave pending an independent investigation into oversight of the department's criminal investigative unit.
- The chief's attorney argued the commission skipped required steps — no public hearing, no specific charges stated, no due process — and threatened to sue if the commission doesn't start over.
- He also raised a conflict-of-interest claim, saying the mayor opposed Peltier from before his hiring and has pushed privately and publicly for his firing.
- Commissioners defended the leave as a temporary, protective step meant to preserve records and investigative integrity, not as discipline.
- A commissioner asked Peltier to submit a written plan for restoring trust and accountability in the department if reinstated, due by Monday.
Outlook: Legal conflict looks likely to escalate, with the chief's attorney signaling he'll file suit and seek depositions from commissioners unless the process restarts with a formal hearing.