Maui Police Commission Votes to Keep Chief Pelletier on Paid Leave

Nov 18, 2026

Maui's police chief stays sidelined with pay while an outside investigator digs into his handling of a corruption case, a mixed outcome that satisfies no one in the community.

  • Commissioners voted 6 to 1 to keep Chief John Pelletier on paid leave instead of reinstating him, with a decision expected in about six months.
  • The case centers on Pelletier's oversight of a unit commander accused of taking bribes from drug dealers and other criminals in exchange for protection.
  • That commander is now in federal custody, and the commission says it needs time to determine whether Pelletier actually broke department policy.
  • Pelletier's attorney says the chief plans to sue the commission next week, while the commission chair insists the leave is necessary for a fair investigation.
  • Public testimony ran for hours, split between residents demanding the chief be reinstated and others accusing the commission of mishandling his hiring.

Outlook: Expect a legal fight to play out alongside the roughly six-month investigation, with no resolution on Pelletier's status until both conclude.

← Latest · Archive