Maui Police Chief Stays on Leave as Attorney Vows Lawsuit
Maui's police commission voted to keep Chief John Pelletier on paid leave, and his attorney says a lawsuit to force his reinstatement could come as soon as next week — a fight that's bad for the department's stability and for Mayor Richard Bissen, who stands accused of pushing the chief out.
- The commission voted 6-1 after about six hours of testimony and a closed-door session to uphold Pelletier's suspension.
- Pelletier's attorney says the county has no real rationale for removing him and didn't follow proper procedures, and plans to sue to get him reinstated.
- The attorney also accuses the mayor of pressuring the commission to get rid of Pelletier; the mayor's office and the commission chair deny it, calling that claim false.
- Pelletier was placed on leave last month during an investigation into his oversight of a now-disbanded police intelligence unit, whose former commander is in federal custody on bribery allegations.
- Public testimony was split, with some retired officers and residents questioning how Pelletier was hired, while off-duty officers showed up to support him.
Outlook: A lawsuit from Pelletier's side is expected within days, setting up a legal fight over whether he gets reinstated as chief.