Maui Police Chief Pelletier Stays on Paid Leave Amid Probe

Nov 19, 2026

Maui's police chief remains sidelined on paid leave as the department's oversight commission spent nearly seven hours hearing public testimony on whether to bring him back, a bad sign for anyone hoping the leadership crisis gets resolved soon.

  • The commission kept Chief John Pelletier on paid administrative leave rather than reinstating him, despite his attorney pushing for an immediate return.
  • Public testimony was split roughly down the middle, with dozens speaking both for and against bringing the chief back.
  • The case stems from a lieutenant who ran the department's criminal intelligence unit and was criminally charged by federal prosecutors; the fallout exposed what commissioners called a lack of transparency, communication, and accountability from the chief.
  • The commission just hired an outside law firm to run an independent investigation into the chief's oversight of that unit, plus a separate incident where a neighbor's home was badly damaged by fireworks; the probe is expected to cost around $50,000 and take six months.
  • The chief's attorney says a lawsuit seeking reinstatement will move forward as a matter of principle, and has accused the mayor of pushing the effort to remove him.

Outlook: Expect a lawsuit from the chief within the week, while the independent investigation keeps him on leave for months before any final decision on his job.

← Latest · Archive