Hawaii elections office proposes new tie-breaker rules

Oct 12, 2026

Hawaii's Office of Elections wants to change how tied races are decided, a small but real fix after a tie threw a state House seat into the courts.

  • The change follows a state Supreme Court ruling over District 43, where Representative Kanani Souza lost her seat to Sheila Maduras after their primary ended in a tie.
  • That tie was settled by pulling names from plastic capsules dropped in a basket.
  • Under the proposal, names could simply be drawn from a container when those capsules aren't on hand.
  • A public hearing on the rule is set for October 26, with oral and written testimony accepted.

Outlook: The rule is likely to be finalized after the hearing, giving Hawaii a simpler fallback the next time a race ends dead even.

← Latest · Archive