Memory Market Cools; Analysts: A Low P/E Doesn't Mean an Immediate Rally
Taiwan's memory stocks have entered a consolidation phase after a sharp run-up — bad news for retail investors who chased the highs, but an opportunity for long-term investors willing to wait.
- Older-generation DDR4 has at times been priced higher than the newer DDR5, as industrial control, networking switch and cloud operators have been unable to move away from it; even Google has been recovering old memory from retired servers as a stopgap.
- Samsung, SK Hynix and Micron have shifted capacity toward higher-margin HBM, leaving DDR4 supply increasingly scarce, with the shortfall unlikely to be filled in the short term.
- Major players have been trimming positions in stocks such as ADATA and Phison at elevated levels, while the share held by retail investors has climbed higher, leaving the market without sustained institutional buying to provide support.
- The world's first two-times leveraged memory ETF was halved in value shortly after listing, seen as a warning sign that the theme has overheated.
- Passive ETFs mostly do not include price-cycle stocks such as Phison and Elite Semiconductor, while actively managed funds show a clear preference for these highly profit-elastic names.
Taiwan's stock market closed lower today, dragged down by U.S. equities, falling more than 240 points to slip below the 47,000 level, with TSMC weakening alongside.
Outlook: Price-cycle stocks typically require six months to a year of shakeout and consolidation, and funds may continue to rotate in the near term toward leading large manufacturers with a genuine capacity moat.