Ballot overage prompts challenge in tied Hawaii primary race
A tied Hawaii state House primary that was settled by drawing a name from a basket is now headed to the state Supreme Court, leaving the seat in limbo.
- Incumbent Kanani Souza and challenger Sheila Medeiros each finished District 43 with the exact same number of votes.
- Medeiros was declared the winner after the chief election officer pulled her name out of a basket.
- Souza has now asked the Supreme Court to review the race, pointing to a state report showing two more ballots counted than envelopes received in one precinct.
- Election officials call it human error and bookkeeping, not fraud, but say a perfect tie makes even a small mismatch a problem.
- Because ballots are separated from their envelopes to keep votes secret, there is no way to trace the extra ballots back to either candidate.
Outlook: The Supreme Court will decide whether to take up the challenge, and until it rules the district has no settled winner.