Suspect in Star of the Sea Church Vandalism to Undergo Mental Health Evaluation

Oct 24, 2026

A man accused of smashing statues and stealing a cross from a historic Big Island church was arrested, and a judge has ordered a mental health evaluation before his case moves forward.

  • Police say 58-year-old Edward Wilsonup Whole broke into the Star of the Sea church, smashed several religious statues, and took a crystal cross later found shattered nearby.
  • He faces property damage and theft charges, with bail set at just $200.
  • The church estimates damage at around $50,000, though repair costs are still unknown since valuing antique religious items is harder than valuing everyday property.
  • A doctor's report on his mental fitness is due by January 5; if found unfit, he'll be treated rather than released, and community members say they want him to get real help, not just punishment.

Outlook: The case is on hold until the mental health evaluation comes back, which will determine whether Wilsonup Whole is released, treated, or prosecuted further.

← Latest · Archive