Nick Shirley sues California over its new law shielding care providers from being filmed

Sep 05, 2026

California's new law makes it far riskier to film and expose suspected fraud at daycare, hospice, and in-home care operations, which is bad news for independent investigators and good news for the operators they target.

  • Nick Shirley is suing the state over AB 2624, signed by Gavin Newsom, which lets designated care and immigration service providers claim $4,000 when their face, address, or plate is posted online.
  • The trigger is subjective — the person filmed only has to show the filmer meant to scare them and that they felt afraid.
  • Old case law on wanted-style posters of abortion doctors makes that intent easy to establish once viewers have shown up at someone's door before.
  • The real weapon is a one-way fee shift: win and you still pay your own lawyers, lose by a single dollar and you pay both sides, turning a $4,000 claim into a seven-figure threat.
  • Each worker can claim separately, so a house with ten staff multiplies the penalty and pushes filmers to settle rather than fight.

Outlook: The suit will likely be tossed for now because the law does not take effect until next October, leaving the challenge to be refiled later.

← Latest · Archive