Vance blamed rising antisemitism in America on immigration while courting big Republican donors, and the pitch landed badly with the very crowd he was trying to win over.

• Vance told the Republican Jewish Coalition that the worst antisemitism comes from immigrants importing old ethnic hatreds, a claim critics call false and a convenient scapegoat.
• The framing is widely seen as a play for donor money ahead of 2028, aimed at a right-wing pro-Israel crowd that does not reflect most Jewish Americans — a large majority of whom oppose the current Israeli government.
• It still was not enough for the room: pro-Israel figures like Sid Rosenberg complained he called Israel only "one of" America's best allies and pushed back on blaming immigrants rather than Americans.
• Meanwhile, dozens of former Israeli generals and two former Israeli prime ministers signed a letter accusing Israel of terrorism and ethnic cleansing in the West Bank.
• The wider charge: criticism of Israel's actions is deliberately conflated with hatred of Jews to shut down debate, and US media largely ignores dissent coming from inside Israel itself.

Outlook: Vance is likely to keep chasing this donor bloc, but the cool reception suggests he will face pressure to go further on Israel to lock in 2028 support.