Dave Smith on Trump's shifting Iran strategy
A skeptical take that the US has stumbled into an unwinnable war with Iran, bad for American troops, the economy, and Trump's credibility.
- Trump keeps flip-flopping by the hour — threatening to bomb Iran and seize its main oil island one minute, then announcing a deal is close the next.
- Iran has been hit hard but won't fold, and history says it can endure years of pressure without giving in.
- There is no real military option: retaking the Strait of Hormuz or toppling the regime would need hundreds of thousands of troops the US doesn't have, especially after arming Ukraine and Israel.
- The whole war is framed as driven by Israel's goals, not a real Iranian nuclear threat, with Israel accused of sabotaging any ceasefire.
- The conflict is dragging on oil prices and the global economy with no clear way out.
Outlook: Diplomacy is the only path, but Trump has no clear plan and the fighting could grind on with no end in sight.